All the searching I did awhile back really paid off. I have a bunch of things marked as favorites and made shopping today a lot easier. Don't get me wrong, I still spent at least an hour searching for new ideas. I finally boiled my choices down. This is what I got:
Giraffe bib and long sleeve onesie by Bean Pickle Sprout
Baby word album by walkerdill
Ultimate baby candy - blanket and diapers and lollipop washcloth and sloop (above) made by jkalea in collaboration with LilBeanBaby
Changing pad made by Bula Bean
Here are some of the other items I was toying around with but didn't get:
If you are looking for baby shower gifts, you should definitely stop by some of these shops.